Features

The Buddha’s Admonition Against Not Severing Lust

All not ready for sudden enlightenment
should walk the gradual path to it now.

– Stonepeace | Books

《大佛顶首楞严经》卷第六:四种决定清净明诲章:第一重戒
[The] Great Buddha’s Crown’s Śūraṅgama Sūtra’s Sixth Scroll: Section [On] Four Kinds [Of] Clear [And] Definitive Instructions [On] Purity: First Heavy Precept

佛告阿难: 汝常闻我毗奈耶中,宣说修行三决定义。所谓摄心为戒,因戒生定,因定发慧,是则名为三无漏学。

Sūtra: [Śākyamuni] Buddha told Ānanda [1], ‘You often hear within my Vinaya [2], proclamation [of] cultivation [of] practice’s Three Definitive Laws [3]. That called gathering [of the] mind as Precepts [4] [is to], due to [the] Precepts, give rise [to] Concentration [5], [and] due to Concentration, give rise [to] Wisdom [6], [which] are then named as [the] Three Learnings Without Outflows [7] [8].

Comments: The Three Learnings can be understood via the analogy of our present minds being polluted, choppy and murky lakes, which require clearing of dirt, representing avoiding of evil by training to observe the precepts. This is followed by calming of the water, representing training for concentration. Finally is to peer through the stilled water to directly perceive the treasure at its bottom, representing training for wisdom. This is the way to train without having the Three Poisons flowing outwards from body, speech and mind.

阿难,云何摄心,我名为戒?若诸世界六道众生,其心不淫,则不随其生死相续。汝修三昧,本出尘劳。淫心不除,尘不可出。

Sūtra: Ānanda, what is gathering [of the] mind, [that] I name as [the] Precepts? If [the] six paths’ [9] sentient beings [of] all worlds, [are with] their minds without sexual [conduct] [10], then [will they] not follow it [with] births [and] deaths [in] continuous succession. [11] You cultivate Samādhi [12], originally [to] exit dusts’ afflictions [13]. [With] sexual [conduct’s] mind not eliminated, [these] dusts cannot [be] exited [14].

Comments: Lust falls under attachment or greed, as the first of the Three Poisons, which keep the rounds of rebirth turning. As thoughts related to lust usually arise as the last thought before death and before rebirth, this is how it traps us life after life. This is why it has to be eradicated for liberation to be attained. As the Buddha was speaking especially to monastics already training with celibacy, he spoke of severing lust directly as a goal to be achieved. For lay Buddhists, celibacy is not expected immediately, though lust should also be severed gradually (eventually) if liberation is to be attained. To train towards this, there is regular practice observation of the Eight Precepts (which requires abstaining from all sexual conduct). Note that this is just the first of four definitive clear instructions for purity to note. With the other three being avoiding of killing, stealing and lying.

纵有多智禅定现前,如不断淫,必落魔道。上品魔王,中品魔民,下品魔女。彼等诸魔,亦有徒众,各各自谓成无上道。

Sūtra: Even if having much wisdom [and] meditative concentration [15] manifesting presently, if not severing sexual [conduct, there will] definitely [be] fall [into] demonic paths [16]. [With those] high grade [becoming] demon kings, [those] middle grade [becoming] demonic subjects, [and those] low grade [becoming] demonic women. Those [and] all other demonic hordes, likewise have assemblies [of] disciples, [with] each [and every] one self-saying [to have] accomplished [the] unsurpassable path [17] [18] [19].

Comments: Those who cultivate the path to Buddhahood without reduction, towards total elimination of lust, as a worst-case scenario, might be reborn as demons. What they have is merely worldly intelligence and not true wisdom, while their ‘meditative concentration’ is also not true. This is so as both true concentration and true wisdom must arise from the precepts being truly observed. What manifests as concentration could be their greedy minds fooling themselves and/or external demons fooling them, so as to mislead them to serve them, and/or to eventually become reborn as one of them. These demons also go against the fourth definitive clear instruction for purity by lying in the gravest way possible with false claims of being Buddhas to mislead more.

我灭度后,末法之中,多此魔民炽盛世间。广行贪淫,为善知识,令诸众生,落爱见坑,失菩提路。汝教世人修三摩地,先断心淫,是名如来先佛世尊,第一决定清净明诲。是故阿难,若不断淫,修禅定者,如蒸沙石,欲其成饭,经百千劫,只名热沙。何以故?此非饭本,沙石成故。

Sūtra: After I enter Parinirvāṇa [20], within [the] Dharma-Ending Age [21], many [of] these demonic subjects [will] flourish [in the] world. Widely practising greedy sexual [conduct], as [false] good-knowing friends [22], enabling many sentient beings, [to] fall [into the] pit [of] attachment [and] delusion, [and] lose [the] Bodhi path [23] [24]. You [should] teach [the] world’s people [who] cultivate Samādhi, first [to] sever [their] minds’ sexual [conduct, as this] is named [as the] Thus Come [One’s [25] and] prior Buddha World-Honoured [Ones’] “First Clear [And] Definitive Instruction [On] Purity”. Therefore, Ānanda, if not severing sexual [conduct], those cultivating meditative concentration, [are] like steaming sand [and] stones, desiring them [to] become rice, [that after] passing [a] hundred thousand kalpas [26], [are] only named [as] hot sand. Why [is this] so? These [are] not rice originally, [with] sand [and] stones composed thus [27].

Comments: We are currently in the age the Buddha warned us about, which is why we should pay special attention to these teachings. Otherwise, we might be fooled by deviant teachers’ encouragement to imagine the continual and unchecked fulfilment of lust is not at all an obstacle on the path to Buddhahood.

汝以淫身,求佛妙果,纵得妙悟,皆是淫根。根本成淫,轮转三途,必不能出。如来涅槃,何路修证?必使淫机,身心俱断,断性亦无,于佛菩提,斯可希冀。

Sūtra: You, with sexual [conduct’s] bodies, seeking Buddhahood’s wonderful fruit, even if attaining wonderful awakening, are all [with] sexual [conduct’s] root. [With the] root becoming sexual [conduct, there is] rebirth [in the] three paths [28], definitely not able [to] exit [them] [29]. [Of the] Thus Come [One’s] Nirvāṇa [30], what [is the] path [of] cultivation [for] realisation? If enabling sexual [conduct’s] intention, [in] body [and] mind [to be] together severed, also without [the] nature [of] severance, [then] of [the] Buddha’s Bodhi [31], this can [be] hoped [for] [32].

Comments: If lust is very strong and left unchecked to grow, as worst-case scenarios, this can lead to rebirth in the three lower realms mentioned, thus being difficult to escape from them, much more from rebirth entirely. For Buddhahood to be attained, the uprooting of lust should be so thorough, that there is no need to suppress it from arising at all. Yet, just as it is difficult, in this Dharma-Ending Age, to instantly and totally sever lust in this lifetime, it is difficult to realise Buddhahood here and now.

However, the Buddha, taught Niànfó (practice of mindfulness of the name of Amitābha Buddha – ‘Āmítuófó’) as a most skilful means to regularly, at least suspend workings of all Three Poisons, including greed as lust in everyday life. With sufficient practice, this can surely also be done on the deathbed. Connecting one’s Buddha-nature with Āmítuófó instead any of the poisons, Pure Land will be reached, where there will be no more outflows of the poisons in practice towards Buddhahood. (Note that Niànfó was taught by the Buddha to be an unsurpassable meditative practice for samādhi: http://purelanders.com/2012/01/16/buddha-mindfulness-is-supreme-meditation)

如我此说,名为佛说。不如此说,即波旬说。

Sūtra: Such that I [have] spoken, [is] named as Buddhas’ speech. Not such [as] spoken, is Pāpīyāms’ [33] speech [34].’

Comments: The Buddha is unequivocal here, directly summing up his above teachings as definitive, and not to be compromised for all goals of liberation (Arhathood and Buddhahood). Any teaching that counters them are not only not conducive for liberation, they are the same as Māra’s words, which lead farther away from liberation, to remain trapped in rebirth.

字汇,小结,注解
Glossary, Summaries And More Notes:

[1] Ānanda (阿难): The Buddha’s personal attendant monk, here representing the audience, including us.

[2] Vinaya (毗奈耶): (Monastic) discipline with moral rules and regulations.

[3] Three Definitive Laws (三决定义): Three Learnings Without Outflows (三无漏学) [7

[4] Precepts (戒): Moral guidelines, especially those taught in this section

[5] Concentration (定): Samādhi (三昧;三摩地) [12]

[6] Wisdom (慧): Insight realised on how to guide one and all to Buddhahood (佛果).

[7] Three Learnings Without Outflows (三无漏学): Precepts (戒) [4], Concentration (定) [5] and Wisdom (慧) [6] that lead to the end of the three poisons (三毒) of greed (attachment) (贪), hatred (aversion) (嗔) and delusion (ignorance) (痴), thus preventing any of them from flowing out through body (身), speech (口) and mind (意).

[8] Summary (1): The Three Definitive Laws (三决定义), which are the Three Learnings Without Outflows (三无漏学) should be practised, beginning with gathering of the mind as Precepts (戒), which in turn gives rise to Concentration (定), which in turn gives rise to Wisdom (慧).

(The Three Learnings can be understood with the analogy of our present minds being polluted, choppy and murky lakes, which require clearing of its dirt, representing avoiding of evil by training to observe the Precepts. This is followed by calming of the water, representing training for Concentration. Finally is to peer through the stilled water to directly perceive and retrieve the treasure at its bottom, representing training for Wisdom.)

[9] Six paths (六道): Realms of hell-beings (地狱众生), hungry ghosts (饿鬼), animals (畜生), human beings (人), asuras (阿修罗) and heavenly beings (天人).

[10] Without sexual conduct (不淫): Avoiding all forms of sexual conduct is necessary for liberation, as lust is one of the primary forms of greed for (fleeting) pleasure that binds us to rebirth. With the last thought usually related to lust before taking rebirth, this karmically connects to the next worldly rebirth. This is how lust traps us life after life, and why it has to be eradicated for liberation. As the Buddha was speaking especially to monastics, who were already training with celibacy, he spoke of severing lust directly, at the level of the mind too.

For lay Buddhists, celibacy is not expected immediately, although sexual misconduct still has to be avoided, while lust should also be severed periodically, gradually and eventually if liberation is to be attained. To train towards this, there can be regular observation of the Eight Precepts (八戒), which requires abstaining from all sexual conduct.

During daily practice sessions and retreats too, including on the deathbed, lust must be relinquished in thought and deed. Wholeheartedly mindful of Buddha (一心念佛) when dying, there should be no more thoughts connected to sex. This effectively becomes renunciation of sexual conduct for good, as there will be no more such thoughts arising after connecting to the Buddha and with reaching of his Pure Land (净土).

[11] When thoughts of sexual conduct are eradicated from the mind, there will be no deeds of sexual conduct, and thus no creation of evil karma (恶业) from sexual conduct that binds us to rebirth (轮回).

[12] Samādhi (三摩地): Meditative concentration (禅定) for progress towards attainment of wisdom (智慧).

[13] Dusts’ afflictions (尘劳): Concerns, burdens or labours (劳) of worldly life. There are the six dusts (六尘) of sight (form) dust (色尘), sound dust (声尘), smell dust (香尘), taste dust (味尘), touch dust (触尘) and dharma (thought) dust (法尘). Afflictions (烦恼) are troubles of suffering arising from relating to the six dusts with the three poisons (三毒) of greed (attachment) (贪), hatred (aversion) (嗔) and delusion (ignorance) (痴).

[14] Summary (2): As the Precepts (戒) observed well form the foundation for cultivating Samādhi (三摩地), that leads to Wisdom (智慧) for liberation (解脱) from all afflictions (烦恼), breaking this First Heavy Precept (第二重戒) against sexual conduct makes liberation impossible.

[15] Meditative concentration (禅定): [12] Samādhi (三昧)

[16] Demonic paths (魔道): Paths of becoming (like) malevolent evil ghosts (恶鬼), by possession and/or in person as demons (魔). The demons taught here can be collectively considered as the demons in the ‘Fifty Aggregates’ Demons Section’《五十阴魔章》, as detailed at the end of this sūtra.

[17] Unsurpassable path (无上道): The way to supreme enlightenment; i.e. the fruit of Buddhahood (佛果).

[18] Self-saying to have accomplished the unsurpassable path (自谓成无上道): This is to break the Fourth Heavy Precept (第四重戒).

[19] Summary (3): If there is much theoretical (but not actual realised) wisdom and practical meditative concentration (禅定), but with breaking of this Precept, due to the strong evil karma (恶业) created, this at best leads to rebirth as demons (魔) with various powers, but never to liberation (解脱). Due to possibly having some remnant good karma (善业), they might be able to lead some minor demons. However, they will mislead themselves and others into thinking they are already Buddhas, (thus creating more evil karma for more suffering to come, keeping liberation even further away).

(True Concentration [定] and true Wisdom [慧] must arise from the Precepts [戒] being truly observed. Otherwise, what manifests as ‘concentration’ or ‘wisdom’ could be from one’s greedy and deluded minds, fooling oneself, and/or from external demons fooling oneself, to mislead one to serve them, and/or to eventually become reborn as one of them.)

[20] Parinirvāṇa (灭度): The Buddha’s relinquishment of his manifested physical form after completing his teachings and fulfilling his karmic affinity with sentient beings in his time.

[21] Dharma-Ending Age (末法时期): This current period of 10,000 years we are in, when the quality of the Right Dharma (正法) being taught, learnt, practised and realised is in general decline.

[22] Good-knowing friends (善知识): Spiritual friends who befriend with sharing of the Right Dharma (正法).

[23] Bodhi path (菩提路): Path to Buddhahood (佛果)

[24] Summary (4): Such evil beings will become innumerable in this Dharma-Ending Age (末法时期), who claim that with sexual conduct, one can attain Buddhahood (佛果), (thus misleading many to also break this Precept. They might claim that sexual conduct is inconsequential to the physical and spiritual welfare of one and all. This clearly does not make sense as sentient beings’ physical and spiritual lives are at stake).

[25] Thus Come One (如来): The Buddha, who ‘as if came’ to be, from awakening of always present Buddha-nature (佛性); potential for Buddhahood.

[26] Kalpas (劫): One world cycle, the time for a world to be formed and destroyed, about 1,334,000,000 years.

[27] Summary (5): Those not severing sexual conduct will not be able to cultivate true meditative concentration (禅定). (All Buddhas teach in the same way for guiding all to perfect their Precepts, so as to perfect meditative Concentration, and to perfect realisation of Wisdom. Those who stubbornly reject this teaching by refusing to see its sensibility surely lack wisdom, while having much passive and/or active greed for sexual conduct and rebirth [轮回].)

[28] Three paths (三途): Realms of hell-beings (地狱众生), hungry ghosts (饿鬼) and animals (畜生). (See Note [9])

[29] Summary (6): So-called ‘awakening’ without severing sexual conduct will either be not very great or even false. (See Note [19]) In the worst cases, there will eventually be rebirth in the three paths (三途) with much suffering when good karma (善业) exhausts, with much evil karma (恶业) left.

[30] Thus Come One’s Nirvāṇa (如来涅槃): Buddhahood (佛果)

[31] Buddha’s Bodhi (佛菩提): Buddhahood (佛果)

[32] Summary (7): To progress towards Buddhahood (佛果), (among other practices needed), sexual intention and conduct should be severed. This severance should be so thorough, that there is no need to suppress lust at all, or to even think of severance.

(Yet, just as it is difficult, in this Dharma-Ending Age [末法时期], to instantly and totally sever lust in this lifetime, it is difficult to realise Buddhahood [佛果] here and now. However, the Buddha taught the practice of mindfulness of Buddha [念佛] as a most skilful means [方便] to regularly, at least suspend workings of all three poisons [三毒], including greed as lust in everyday life. [See Note [10]

With sufficient personal practice and support-chanting [助念], this can surely also be done on the deathbed too. Connecting one’s Buddha-nature [佛性] with Āmítuófó [阿弥陀佛: Amitā(bha) Buddha] instead any of the poisons, his Pure Land [净土] will be reached, where there will be no more outflows of the poisons, with the swiftest progress towards Buddhahood.

Having connection of limited Self-power [自力] with the Buddha’s great Other-power [他力], mindfulness of Buddha was also taught by the Buddha to be an unsurpassable meditative practice [for Samādhi (三摩地)]. From the Mahāsaṃnipāta [Great Collection] Sūtra《大集经》, ‘If a person is only mindful of Āmítuófó, this is named as the unsurpassable, profound and wonderful meditation.’ [若人但念阿弥陀,是名无上深妙禅。])

[33] Pāpīyāms (波旬): Māra-Pāpīyāms (魔波旬) in full. ‘Pāpīyāms’ is an epithet meaning ‘The Evil One’. ‘Māra’ (魔罗) means ‘Bringer Of Death’. He is the Demon King (魔王), a god ruling the Sixth Desire Realm Heaven (欲界天), as a heavenly demon (天魔). He is also named Namuci (那牟质), which means ‘Non-Releaser’, as he personifies death, which does not allow anyone to escape from its grasp (unless with the Right Dharma [正法] practised in time).

[34] Summary (8): The Buddha is thus unequivocally conclusive on the above, while warning all that any other teachings that counter these are not only non-Buddhist teachings, but are those of the most evil one, capable of harming many sentient beings’ physical and spiritual lives, keeping one another trapped in rebirth. These teachings are not to be compromised for the goal of Buddhahood.

Namo Amituofo : Translation, glossary, notes and summaries by Shen Shi’an

Related Articles:

The Buddha’s Second Definitive Pure And Clear Instruction
https://thedailyenlightenment.com/2016/06/how-the-buddha-eventually-advocated-veganism
The Buddha’s Fourth Definitive Pure And Clear Instruction
https://thedailyenlightenment.com/2015/01/the-buddhas-admonition-against-making-false-spiritual-claims

Please Be Mindful Of Your Speech, Namo Amituofo!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

error: Alert: Content is protected !!